Skip to content

The Spiritual Life

  • Meaning Of Life
    • Healthy Living
    • Death
    • Afterlife
      • Heaven
      • Hell
    • Dreams
    • Relationships
      • Family
    • Environment
    • Animals
  • Religion
    • Religion and Science
      • Creation and Evolution
        • Creationism
        • Evolution
    • Eschatology
    • Religions
    • Middle Eastern Religions
      • Christianity
        • Catholicism
        • Eastern Christianity
        • Protestantism
        • Nontrinitarianism
        • The Trinity
        • Jesus
        • The Bible
        • Mary (Mother of Jesus)
      • Judaism
      • Islam
        • Shia Islam
        • Sufism
        • Muhammad
        • The Quran
        • Hadith
    • Indian Religions
      • Buddhism
      • Hinduism
      • Jainism
      • Sikhism
    • East Asian Religions
      • Confucianism
      • Taoism
      • Shintoism
    • New Religious Movements
      • Satanism
    • Indigenous Religions
    • Historical Religions
  • Faith
    • God
      • The Existence of God
      • Conceptions of God
      • Atheism
      • Attributes of God
      • Names of God
    • Destiny & Free Will
    • Sin
      • Repentance
    • Prophets
      • Jesus
      • Mary (Mother of Jesus)
      • Muhammad
    • Extraterrestrial Life
      • Angels
      • Spirit And Soul
      • Satan
    • Sacred Texts
      • Buddhism’s Sacred Texts
      • Hinduism’s Sacred Texts
      • Christianity’s Religious Texts
        • The Bible
        • Mormonism’s Sacred Texts
      • Islamic Sacred Texts
        • The Quran
        • Hadith
      • Judaism’s Religious Texts
  • Prayer and Worship
    • Prayer
    • Worship
    • Prayers
  • Spirituality
    • Fasting
    • Meditation
    • Yoga
    • Sufism
    • Music
    • Poetry
  • Virtues
  • Wisdom
    • Philosophy
    • Philosophers
    • Folktales
    • Proverbs
  • Inspirational Quotes
    • Quotes by Authors
    • Quotes By Topics
  • About
    • Contact Us
    • Policies
    • Article Submission Guidelines
    • Copyrights
  • Home
  • Meaning Of Life
    • Healthy Living
    • Death
    • Afterlife
      • Heaven
      • Hell
    • Dreams
    • Relationships
      • Family
    • Environment
    • Animals
  • Religion
    • Religion and Science
      • Creation and Evolution
        • Creationism
        • Evolution
    • Eschatology
    • Religions
    • Middle Eastern Religions
      • Christianity
        • Catholicism
        • Eastern Christianity
        • Protestantism
        • Nontrinitarianism
        • The Trinity
        • Jesus
        • The Bible
        • Mary (Mother of Jesus)
      • Judaism
      • Islam
        • Shia Islam
        • Sufism
        • Muhammad
        • The Quran
        • Hadith
    • Indian Religions
      • Buddhism
      • Hinduism
      • Jainism
      • Sikhism
    • East Asian Religions
      • Confucianism
      • Taoism
      • Shintoism
    • New Religious Movements
      • Satanism
    • Indigenous Religions
    • Historical Religions
  • Faith
    • God
      • The Existence of God
      • Conceptions of God
      • Atheism
      • Attributes of God
      • Names of God
    • Destiny & Free Will
    • Sin
      • Repentance
    • Prophets
      • Jesus
      • Mary (Mother of Jesus)
      • Muhammad
    • Extraterrestrial Life
      • Angels
      • Spirit And Soul
      • Satan
    • Sacred Texts
      • Buddhism’s Sacred Texts
      • Hinduism’s Sacred Texts
      • Christianity’s Religious Texts
        • The Bible
        • Mormonism’s Sacred Texts
      • Islamic Sacred Texts
        • The Quran
        • Hadith
      • Judaism’s Religious Texts
  • Prayer and Worship
    • Prayer
    • Worship
    • Prayers
  • Spirituality
    • Fasting
    • Meditation
    • Yoga
    • Sufism
    • Music
    • Poetry
  • Virtues
  • Wisdom
    • Philosophy
    • Philosophers
    • Folktales
    • Proverbs
  • Inspirational Quotes
    • Quotes by Authors
    • Quotes By Topics
  • About
    • Contact Us
    • Policies
    • Article Submission Guidelines
    • Copyrights
  • Home

The Spiritual Life

“Windows To Spirituality”

new testament

An Historical Account Of Two Notable Corruptions Of Scripture

An Historical Account Of Two Notable Corruptions Of Scripture

An Historical Account of Two Notable Corruptions of Scripture is a dissertation by the English mathematician and scholar Isaac Newton. This was sent in a letter to John Locke on 14 November 1690 and built upon the textual work of Richard Simon and his own research. The text was first published in English in 1754, 27 years after his death. The account claimed to review all the textual evidence available from ancient sources on two disputed Bible passages: 1 John 5:7 and 1 Timothy 3:16.

Newton describes this letter as “an account of what the reading has been in all ages, and what steps it has been changed, as far as I can hitherto determine by records”, and “a criticism concerning a text of Scripture”. He blames “the Roman church” for many abuses in the world and accuses it of “pious frauds”. He adds that “the more learned and quick-sighted men, as Luther, Erasmus, Bullinger, Grotius, and some others, would not dissemble their knowledge”.

new testament

The New Testament

1 John 5:7

See also: Comma Johanneum

In the King James Version Bible, 1 John 5:7 reads:

For there are three that bear record in heaven, the Father, the Word, and the Holy Ghost: and these three are one.

Using the writings of the early Church Fathers, the Greek and Latin manuscripts and the testimony of the first versions of the Bible, Newton claims to have demonstrated that the words “in heaven, the Father, the Word, and the Holy Ghost: and these three are one”, that support the Trinity doctrine, did not appear in the original Greek Scriptures. He then attempts to demonstrate that the purportedly spurious reading crept into the Latin versions, first as a marginal note, and later into the text itself. He noted that “the Æthiopic, Syriac, Arabic, Armenian, and Slavonic versions, still in use in the several Eastern nations, Ethiopia, Egypt, Syria, Mesopotamia, Armenia, Muscovy, and some others, are strangers to this reading”. He argued that it was first taken into a Greek text in 1515 by Cardinal Ximenes on the strength of a late Greek manuscript ‘corrected’ from the Latin. Finally, Newton considered the sense and context of the verse, concluding that removing the interpolation makes “the sense plain and natural, and the argument full and strong; but if you insert the testimony of ‘the Three in Heaven’ you interrupt and spoil it.”Today most versions of the Bible are from the Critical Text and omit this verse, or retain it as only a marginal reading.

1 Timothy 3:16

The shorter portion of Newton’s dissertation was concerned with 1 Timothy 3:16, which reads (in the King James Version):

And without controversy great is the mystery of godliness: God was manifest in the flesh, justified in the Spirit, seen of angels, preached unto the Gentiles, believed on in the world, received up into glory.

Newton argued that, by a small alteration in the Greek text, the word “God” was substituted to make the phrase read “God was manifest in the flesh” instead of “which was manifested in the flesh”. He attempted to demonstrate that early Church writers in referring to the verse knew nothing of such an alteration.

Summary of both passages

Isaac Newton

Isaac Newton

Newton concludes: “If the ancient churches in debating and deciding the greatest mysteries of religion, knew nothing of these two texts, I understand not, why we should be so fond of them now the debates are over.” With minor exceptions, it was only in the nineteenth century that Bible translations appeared changing these passages. Modern versions of the Bible from the Critical Text usually omit the addition to 1 John 5:7, but some place it in a footnote, with a comment indicating that “it is not found in the earliest manuscripts”. Modern translations of 1 Timothy 3:16 following the Critical Text now typically replace “God” with “He” or “He who”, while the literal Emphasized has “who”. A number of papers in the years following responded to Newton, notably John Berriman in 1741, who had seen at least some of Newton’s text prior to publication. Later, Frederick Nolan in 1815, Ebenezer Henderson in 1830 and John William Burgon in the Revision Revised in 1883 all contributed substantially to the verse discussion.

Historical background

Newton did not publish these findings during his lifetime, likely due to the political climate. Those who wrote against the doctrine of the Trinity were subject to persecution in England. The Blasphemy Act 1697 made it an offence to deny one of the persons of the Trinity to be God, punishable with loss of office and employment on the first occasion, further legal ramifications on the second occasion, and imprisonment without hope for bail on the third occasion. Newton’s friend William Whiston (translator of the works of Josephus) lost his professorship at Cambridge for this reason in 1711. In 1693 a pamphlet attacking the Trinity was burned by order of the House of Lords, and the next year its printer and author were prosecuted. In 1697 Thomas Aikenhead, an eighteen-year-old student charged with denying the Trinity, was hanged at Edinburgh, Scotland.

The dissertation was published in 1754.

Adapted from Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Telegram (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • More
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Skype (Opens in new window)

Related

  • Next story Gospel Harmony
  • Previous story The Holy Quran’s Invitation To Christians

You must log in to post a comment.

Spiritual Happiness
Spiritual Happiness

The Meaning of Life

  • Friendship

    Friendship

  • Natural Reserve Environment Environmental Protection

    At The Threshold Of A New Millennium

  • Bonding between a mother and child

    Human Bonding

  • Thanatos

    Thanatos

Prayers and Worship

  • Prayer and Worship category

    Prayers Of Praise

  • The Seven Sacraments

    Sacrament

  • praying

    Prayers For the Dignity Of Human Life

  • A sermon, or homily, is an element of a church service.

    Church Service

Spirituality

  • Desk

    Redaction Criticism

  • Salad

    Christian Vegetarianism

  • The Acts of the Apostles

    Historical Reliability Of The Acts Of The Apostles

  • Hokusai, The Lantern Ghost

    Tsukumogami

Religion

  • The Concept of Science and Technology

  • People Lady Woman Man Guy Praying Praise Singing

    Religious Experience

  • OLAM HA-BA (World to come)

    OLAM HA-BA (World to come)

  • Fire worship in Fire Temple

    Fire Worship

  • Meaning Of Life
    • Healthy Living
    • Death
    • Afterlife
      • Heaven
      • Hell
    • Dreams
    • Relationships
      • Family
    • Environment
    • Animals
  • Religion
    • Religion and Science
      • Creation and Evolution
        • Creationism
        • Evolution
    • Eschatology
    • Religions
    • Middle Eastern Religions
      • Christianity
        • Catholicism
        • Eastern Christianity
        • Protestantism
        • Nontrinitarianism
        • The Trinity
        • Jesus
        • The Bible
        • Mary (Mother of Jesus)
      • Judaism
      • Islam
        • Shia Islam
        • Sufism
        • Muhammad
        • The Quran
        • Hadith
    • Indian Religions
      • Buddhism
      • Hinduism
      • Jainism
      • Sikhism
    • East Asian Religions
      • Confucianism
      • Taoism
      • Shintoism
    • New Religious Movements
      • Satanism
    • Indigenous Religions
    • Historical Religions
  • Faith
    • God
      • The Existence of God
      • Conceptions of God
      • Atheism
      • Attributes of God
      • Names of God
    • Destiny & Free Will
    • Sin
      • Repentance
    • Prophets
      • Jesus
      • Mary (Mother of Jesus)
      • Muhammad
    • Extraterrestrial Life
      • Angels
      • Spirit And Soul
      • Satan
    • Sacred Texts
      • Buddhism’s Sacred Texts
      • Hinduism’s Sacred Texts
      • Christianity’s Religious Texts
        • The Bible
        • Mormonism’s Sacred Texts
      • Islamic Sacred Texts
        • The Quran
        • Hadith
      • Judaism’s Religious Texts
  • Prayer and Worship
    • Prayer
    • Worship
    • Prayers
  • Spirituality
    • Fasting
    • Meditation
    • Yoga
    • Sufism
    • Music
    • Poetry
  • Virtues
  • Wisdom
    • Philosophy
    • Philosophers
    • Folktales
    • Proverbs
  • Inspirational Quotes
    • Quotes by Authors
    • Quotes By Topics
  • About
    • Contact Us
    • Policies
    • Article Submission Guidelines
    • Copyrights
  • Home

The Spiritual Life © 2010 - 2030. All Rights Reserved.

Scroll Up